Eichmann in the Ivy

Three weeks after Jane Doe was gang raped at a frat house at Cornell, she phoned one of her alleged rapists, sophomore Winston Lee. According to records released to the New York Times, Lee allegedly forced oral sex upon Jane Doe and snorted ketamine off her body. He was suspended for two years, put on probation upon his return, and required to write an essay about what he had learned from the experience.

Yesterday, we learned that this is what Lee said to Jane Doe on the phone:

I’m so sorry about all, like, the backlash you’re getting from this, by the way…Oh, dude, I’m, I’m so sorry. Like, I feel so bad for you, dude.

Almost immediately after the rape, the entire campus began hearing about it. It would have been hard for students not to haven heard about it, given that more than 50 fraternity brothers had been snapchatting about it all evening. Upon hearing about it, students talked about it. As so often happens, the victim, not the victimizer, became the butt of gossip, jokes, scandal, and commentary. Hence, the empathy and commiseration from Lee for Jane Doe, one student to another.

Hearing this jewel of a comment from Lee, I couldn’t help thinking back to two moments from the interrogation of Adolf Eichmann. I know the move from a gang rape at Cornell to the Holocaust will seem large, but hear me out.

As Hannah Arendt reports in Eichmann in Jerusalem, Eichmann, during his interrogation, told a macabre story about the time Berthold Storfer, a leader of the Jewish community in Vienna, now in Auschwitz, requested to see Eichmann. Storfer had previously worked with Eichmann in Vienna, securing the transport of thousands of Jews to Palestine, as well as the expulsion of other Jews to their deaths in the East. But now Storfer was doing slave labor in Auschwitz, facing his likely end. When Eichmann met with him, he said to Storfer, “Well, my dear old friend, we certainly got it! What rotten luck!” Storfer was killed six weeks later.

At another moment in his interrogation, David Cesarini writes in Becoming Eichmann, Eichmann was told by his Israeli interrogator, Avner Less, that the Nazis had murdered Less’s father in Auschwitz. Ever officious and proper, Eichmann always referred to Less by his rank: captain, or Hauptmann in German. Told by Less about the murder, Eichmann responded, “But that’s horrible, Herr Hauptmann! That’s horrible!”

Arendt was struck by two features of Eichmann, both captured in these stories. First, how stupid he was. By stupid, she did not mean without intelligence or lacking intellect. She meant something more like callow, lacking any sense of judgment, not being able to see what was right in front of his nose, particularly a person he had harmed, not being able to see the world from the perspective of those whose world he had undone. Only Eichmann could look a Jew in the eye—one about to be murdered by Eichmann’s people, another whose father had been murdered by Eichmann’s people—and express sorrow and empathy for their situation, as if he had nothing to do with it at all. Eichmann, in his old boy way, said, what rotten luck, that’s horrible. Winston Lee, in his frat boy way, says, I feel so bad for you dude.

Second, Arendt couldn’t quite get her head around the fact that Eichmann was part of the German ruling class. At points, she even downplayed Eichmann’s leadership. Not because she was looking to exonerate him—far from it—but because she found it hard to reconcile his outsized agency in killing the Jews with his irrepressible conformity and tendency to follow other people, his sense of himself as so much flotsam and jetsom. Here was a leader who helped kill million of Jews, playing the part of the most abject follower, almost as if he were a victim himself.

It’s easy for people to forget in this Cornell story that these young men are at an Ivy League university, which selected them for their achievement and promise, and will be sending them on, one day, to the most elite circles of American power, stamped with the certification of the Ivy League. These are future leaders of the United States. Yet all of them, in their subsequent conversations with Jane Doe or comments to Cornell’s investigators, disclaim all leadership and agency in this rape. One man even suggests that it was not Jane Doe, but perhaps he, who was raped: because he was so intoxicated, he couldn’t possibly have given his consent to sexual acts with Doe.

If there’s a reason this case has touched a nerve, it’s not only the horror of what happened to Jane Doe; it’s also this combination of stupidity, in the Arendtian sense, and disclaimer of agency by men who will go on to rule the country, that seems so resonant. It doesn’t seem as if Cornell is doing a bad job of educating men to the ruling class. It seems as if it’s doing a perfect job, preparing these men for exactly the kind of stupidity and power the country has come to expect from its leaders.

One last thought. It’s not said enough that one of the many contributions of the MeToo movement was to completely change the popular understanding of rape and sexual assault in this country. When I was growing up, the stories the culture told itself about rape focused on strangers and the working class. Think of films like A Clockwork Orange, Accused, and Extremities. In each case, it’s a stranger or strangers who rape a woman. In two cases, the woman raped is either rich or a member of the professional middle class. In at least two cases, the rapists are working class, most memorably in A Clockwork Orange. In the play version of Extremities, the rapist is named “Raul,” who’s kind of an itinerant sort of handyman; in the movie, they had the good sense to change his name to “Joe,” though he’s still depicted as working class.

MeToo changed all that. The rapists and harassers were not just people women knew, sometimes knew quite well. They were bosses and employers, sometimes super bosses like Harvey Weinstein, and part of the uber-rich, like Jeffrey Epstein. They worked in film, high-end publishing, television, finance, universities, corporate America. They were not men who were uneducated or unskilled or declassed. They were the cream of the crop, graduates of Ivy League schools and all the rest. They were stupid, again in the Arendtian sense. And they did immense harm. They still do.


Discover more from Corey Robin

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

3 Comments

  1. Biz Lat | #

    I wonder which high-ranking Nazi Corey used for comparison in his article on the Duke lacrosse team.

  2. Vivian Tseng | #

    I think your point is spot on: both men were speaking from the same playbook of immorality. But isn’t it just deliberate deflection? Both constructing the false narrative to escape accountability: placing the perpetrator of evil in the same moral universe as his victims; saying we are the same, both human, both with equal agency, so the victims got what they deserved either/or/and because of their actions, who they are, their preordained status in the world in which all reside and the perpetrators did nothing culpablely wrong because they, like their victims, acted in accordance with the rules of that perverse universe which the perpetrators’ false narrative constructed. It’s just a perverse, exaggerated version of DARVO.

  3. lfc2014 | #

    From the post:
    “It’s easy for people to forget in this Cornell story that these young men are at an Ivy League university, which selected them for their achievement and promise, and will be sending them on, one day, to the most elite circles of American power, stamped with the certification of the Ivy League. These are future leaders of the United States.”

    The assumption or belief or assertion (choose your preferred word) that every graduate of an Ivy League university ends up in “the most elite circles of American power” is false. Some will end up in those circles and others won’t. Some don’t even want to end up in those circles. I could say more on this point but I’ll leave it at that.

Leave a Reply