From the Jew Bill to the Mamdani Act

In 1753, Britain considered a bill to allow the naturalization of the country’s 4,000 foreign-born Jews. Formally titled “An Act to permit Persons professing the Jewish Religion to be naturalized by Parliament,” the bill was widely known as the “Jew Bill.” Though it initially passed both houses of Parliament, it was repealed after a vicious campaign of antisemitism and nativism, led by the Tories.

Today’s Republican Islamophobes in Congress are more brazen. They don’t wait for the public to do their dirty work of name-calling. They have actually titled a bill that would, among other things, strip Muslim citizens of their citizenship, the “MAMDANI Act.”

When people say that the historic Jewish Question, which was about whether Jews could ever be accepted and incorporated as full and equal members of the state, has become the Muslim Question, this is what they mean.


Discover more from Corey Robin

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

5 Comments

  1. Simon During | #

    Not sure “vicious campaign” by the Tories is quite right. The backlash against the Act seems largely to have been spontaneous, if often encouraged by local vicars many of whom admittedly were no friends of Whiggism. It caught most people by surprise. Nor was the Act any kind of liberation Act, it was mainly designed to make it easier for the state to secure capital by enabling more access to rich Jewish financiers.

    • Corey Robin | #

      Thomas Perry’s book, Public Opinion, Propaganda, and Politics in Eighteenth-Century England: A Study of the Jew Bill of 1753, which I’ve just read, makes it seem like the Tory campaign was not only vicious but also extremely cynical, geared as it was to winning the elections of 1754. It certainly caught people by surprise, as there hadn’t been anything like it in quite some time, but that doesn’t diminish the role of the Tories in stirring things up.

  2. marc sobel | #

Leave a Reply