Rosh Hashanah at Brooklyn College
Here are some findings from the last two days of the New York Times.
- “Zohran Mamdani has opened a commanding lead in the race for mayor of New York City, buoyed by support for his affordability platform.”
- Mamdani leads among Black voters, Latino voters, Asian voters, and white voters.
- Of all the candidates in the race, Mamdani also has the highest percentage of support among Jewish voters. His support among younger and educated voters is off the charts. Both of these facts are important for what I will say below.
- A majority of NYC voters do not believe that criticizing Israel is antisemitic.
- Nearly twice as many NYC voters sympathize with Palestinians over Israelis as opposed to Israelis over Palestinians. Among young voters (younger than 29), the ratio of support for Palestinians over Israelis jumps to more than 5 to 1.
- A plurality of all voters think that Mamdani has the best response, of any of the candidates, to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.
Let’s put these pieces together.
New Yorkers stand with Palestine. New Yorkers think that Mamdani has the best position of any of the mayoral candidates on Palestine. Jewish New Yorkers stand with Mamdani. Younger (and educated) New Yorkers overwhelmingly stand with Mamdani. Many of those younger New Yorkers are students, in the process of being educated. Some of those students attend CUNY.
This past weekend, Mamdani went to Brooklyn College, where he said that students and staff and faculty at CUNY should not be punished for their activism on behalf of Palestine.
Brooklyn College has fired four instructors for their activism on Palestine and is hauling up five full-time faculty and one staff member for investigation and possible discipline over their activism on Palestine. Several of these instructors and faculty and staff are Jewish; all but one of them are women.
All of this repression is being done in the name of protecting Jewish students from alleged antisemitism on campus, even though New Yorkers, in the very Jewish city of New York, reject the idea that criticizing Israel is antisemitic. Jewish students belong to two constituencies—Jewish New Yorkers and New York students—who are planning to vote for Zohran Mamdani. Zohran Mamdani not only supports the position on Palestine that these instructors, staff, and full-time faculty have taken; he has also spoken out on behalf of them and said that CUNY should not be punishing them.
Rosh Hashanah is a holiday connected to Abraham, whose secret, the tradition tells us, is that he knew how to begin again. As we head into this new school year, this new Jewish new year, and this mayoral election, Brooklyn College and CUNY have an opportunity: to begin again. I hope they take it.
Discover more from Corey Robin
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
-
Yes. I agree completely, while noting your comments are un-typically clear and pointed. the only thing I would add is, as New Yorkers and Americans, violence against Jews or Muslims will not and can not be tolerated.
-
My support for Palestinian rights did not cause the recent increase in antisemitism; that was caused by Netanyahu and his theocratic supporters. For decades now American schools have taught students about Mandela, MLK, and the civil rights movement. Young people have translated that education into support for those who are oppressed.
-
-
Though it doesn’t change your overall conclusions, it’s worth noting that although Mamdani does win the Jewish vote with 31%, that’s only because the anti-Mamdani Jewish vote is split among Cuomo, Sliwa, and Adams. Since virtually all of the Jewish Sliwa and Adams voters would choose Cuomo over Mamdani, Cuomo wins a two way race against Mamdani 64%-31%. Mamdani probably does better among younger Jews and Jewish students. I actually find 31% very encouraging, and a big change from earlier times.