It Feels Like the First Time

Until 2006, Rabbi Ismar Schorsch was chancellor of the Jewish Theological Seminary, which is the leading academic and rabbinical training institute for Conservative Judaism. Which is all the more reason to be surprised, even shocked, by what he says in this interview with Peter Beinart.

You have to understand the position of the JTS within American, even international Jewry, and the rabbinate it produces, to grapple with the full weight of Rabbi Schorsch’s statement. And know that he’s now 89 years old, and what it must be like, to have lived a full Jewish life to that age, to have survived and been a refugee from Kristallnacht in Nazi Germany, to have created this world of rabbinic Judaism in the United States, and now be approaching one’s end, only to have to think and say the things he says here.

Rabbi Schorsch compares the silence, complacency, and support of Jewish religious leaders since the Israeli assault on Gaza to the silence of Christian theologians and religious leaders under Nazi Germany. (NB: If I were to make such a claim, under the IHRA definition of antisemitism that has been adopted by CUNY and other universities, I could be investigated and fired.)

Rabbi Schorsch reminds Jews that Ezekiel tells us that before the destruction of First Temple, God already had fled the sanctuary and essentially given up on his relationship with the Jews because of their idolatry. That—God’s departure—is what, in the end, made possible their loss of the Temple. In a separate writing this past summer, Rabbi Schorsch invokes a Talmudic teaching that says amid the fire that consumed the Temple, younger priests, priests in training (why that detail, I wonder?), ran up to the rooftop to declare to God, “Because we have failed to be faithful stewards of Your sanctuary we are returning its keys to You.” And then threw themselves into the fire.

Rabbi Schorsch’s message is clear: Jews have betrayed their covenant with God in the past, and they paid for it by God’s declaring them unworthy of their stewardship of Jerusalem.

Rabbi Schorsch lastly says that rabbis and Jews throughout America need to start reading the Prophets again. I had the oddest experience in hearing him say that. For 35 years, as a thinking Jewish adult, I’ve heard virtually every Jewish religious leader, political leader, or writer make some obligatory nod to the prophetic traditions of Judaism. Each time, the nod was followed by some bland injunction to be righteous in our everyday life, to give to the poor, support rights for some group or another, yada yada yada. I can’t tell you how many B’Nai Mitzvah I’ve been to over the years, where the 13-year-old in question is led to make some connection between the prophetic writings and how they act as team captain on the playing field of some sport or another.

The irony of these invocations is always almost too painful to bear: The whole purpose of the Prophets was to find a way, through language, of shocking the Jews out of their complacency. The reason these readings were canonized as part of the Hebrew Bible was that the rabbis were all too aware of how easy it is to fall asleep, literally and figuratively, in synagogue. Something needs to prod and poke us to life. The Mishna warns, “Whoever makes his prayer a fixed task, his prayer is not a true supplication.” The Talmud demands, “One’s prayer should be made new each day.” “As new water flows from the well each hour, so Israel renews its song.” To make our prayer new each day, as if we were hearing the word of God for the first time, is partly why we have the Prophets. But the truth of the matter is that for decades, we’ve recited passages from Isaiah and Ezekiel and Amos to the opposite effect, as if they were the most ritualistic chant. Or cant.

That’s why it was so strange, listening to Rabbi Schorsch, to my find myself flinching at his simple statement. We need to start reading and studying the Prophets again. He said it so simply, so quietly, but it was as if I had been shaken by a thunderstorm. I flinched. Not because of what Israel is doing in Gaza, but because of what we, Jews, are not doing about what Israel is doing in Gaza. Because we are not connecting these words, our words, to the world, the world we have helped to make. That’s the purpose of the Prophets. To get us to hear the words of the service, and of the entire Hebrew Bible, as if for the first time.

Come Yom Kippur this September, I’ll be hearing the words of Isaiah that we hear every year, but for the first time.

May we all:

Is this the fast that I have chosen? The day for a man to afflict his soul? Is it to bow down his head as a bulrush, and to spread sackcloth and ashes under him? Will you call this a fast, and an acceptable day to the Lord? Is not this the fast that I have chosen? To loose the fetters of wickedness, to undo the bands of the yoke, and to let the oppressed go free, and that you break every yoke?

If you’re still with me and wondering about these videos, there’s a long tradition in Judaism that sees a parallel between the love between two people and the love between God and God’s people. One of my favorite rabbis used to describe the prayer Avi Malkeinu as “the great love song of the Jewish people.” And there’s, of course, the Song of Songs. Anyway, music often conveys the same thought and feeling. So whether it’s Foreigner or Roberta Flack or Shir HaShirim, you get the idea of what it means to encounter someone or something for the first time.


Discover more from Corey Robin

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

4 Comments

  1. john van sickle | #

    your clear and bitter insight calling up the prophetic voice stirs a stranger to feel next of kin

    • Seekonk | #

      Amen.

  2. edwardripple31312fecc0 | #

    Thank you for this post Prof.

  3. Es | #

    Despite the enlighten council of Rabbi Schorsch, Israel behaves like nations have always behaved. Today’s world cannot tolerated tolerate Israel’s behavior if Mankind expects to survive the future, even acknowledging hypocritical sanctions towards Israel. In a way, expecting Israel to be more enlightened than ourselves Is a form of antisemitism.

Leave a Reply