The Reactionary Mind of Stephen Miller

I was amused to read today that in the course of railing against protesters in Washington, DC, Stephen Miller made a repeated point of calling them old and white. Not simply because the base of the Republican party is old and white. But also because he so perfectly illustrates a point I made years ago, in The Reactionary Mind, about how the right so often mimics the left:

Conservatives often are the left’s best students. Sometimes, their studies are self-conscious and strategic, as they look to the left for ways to bend new vernaculars, or new media, to their suddenly delegitimated aims….At other times, the education of the conservative is unknowing, happening, as it were, behind his back. By resisting and thus engaging with the progressive argument day after day, he comes to be influenced, often in spite of himself, by the very movement he opposes. Setting out to bend a vernacular to his will, he finds his will bent by the vernacular.

I have a hunch that Miller’s invective against old white people is an instance of the second kind of education, the one that happens behind the conservative’s back, without his realizing it.


Discover more from Corey Robin

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

One Comment

  1. jonnybutter | #

    This is an interesting phenomenon, among other reasons because of the proximate motivation for doing the second kind of education: in the US the RW are constantly, almost reflexively, probing liberals and liberalism for psycho-rhetorical weakness, and are willing to use whatever they find, if only glancingly, even if it is ideologically dissonant. The point is to know your foe better than they know themselves, to find your opponent’s blind spots about themselves, which the RW has been very good at vis a vis the Democrats (and Dems have been complete slobs about for a long time), and hack away at it, like beavers.

Leave a Reply