Please, no more of your light in dark times
Why do academics and journalists and writers need to announce their professional good news or that of a friend or colleague or department with these cringey “amid the dark times, a bit of light” introductions?
If you think these are dark times, the fact that a journal just accepted your article—or a publisher signed a contract for your co-edited anthology or your friend is now the dean or a favorite writer just got hired by a magazine—well, you can’t really believe any of this illuminates the darkness.
Can’t you simply tell us your good news and trust that we’ll be happy for you without our having to run it through the cash register of the universe to see whether and how it balances out the fact that a lot of immigrants are being deported? As you can see, it doesn’t cash anything out.
Even at the level of feelings, it’s hard for me to believe that people’s mood is improved from one minute to the next by scrolling from the latest headline about trans kids being denied care to your post about a colleague getting promoted. It’s just your good news, and that’s fine, and that’s enough for you and us to take some pleasure in it.
I’m pretty certain I’m right about this, even if people tell you otherwise.
If you do want to a change of scenery, at least temporarily, read this wonderful essay by Philip Lopate, from 1979, about his experience staging Uncle Vanya with a bunch of students at an elementary school in Manhattan. Tender yet unsentimental, it will take you, however briefly, to a world beyond this one.
Discover more from Corey Robin
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
-
Agreed, that sanctimonious stuff annoys me no end in these dark times, e.g. raving about your special privileged grandkids (at my age cohort). What bugs me also people posting on fb that they did Wordle in 3. Gee, brilliant…
-
I have a feeling that something else is going on but my response is long… and I decided I wanted people who had not read this post to read my response.
So I posted it here: