It’s the Only Face I Have

One of the big mistakes we make when we think about fear is to oppose fear to hope. Hope against fear, that’s the credo. And it’s badly mistaken.

Nadezdha Mandelstam was one of the great writers on Stalinism. Her husband, the poet Osip Mandelstam, was murdered in 1938. She survived the purges and went on to write a miracle of a memoir titled, aptly, Hope Against Hope.

This is what she had to say on the topic of hope and fear:

Until a short time before, I had been full of concern for all my friends and relatives, for my work, for everything I set store by. Now this concern was gone—and fear, too…Having entered a realm of non-being, I had lost the sense of death. In the face of doom, even fear disappears. Fear is a gleam of hope, the will to live, self-assertion. It is a deeply European feeling, nurtured on a self-respect, the sense of one’s own worth, rights, needs and desires. A man clings to what is his, and fears to lose it. Fear and hope are bound up with each other. Losing hope, we lose fear as well—there is nothing to be afraid for.

When you read through the archives of McCarthyism, you get a very clear sense of what Mandelstam is talking about. Many of the people who gave in to the fear of the red hunters—whether those hunters were part of the state or the private sector, Hollywood or the universities, Congress or the FBI, churches or synagogues—talked, often quite eloquently, how their fear was not a function of their being reduced to the most abject form of animal life, but instead, was a product of all that they wanted and hoped for from life. Hobbes, incidentally, understood this, too, which is why he remains the greatest political theorist of fear to this day.

When Richard Schlatter, who was a professor at Rutgers, was called to name names to HUAC, he gave in to the Committee. “It was not just the question of losing my job,” he said. “One can always find a way to live. But the only way in which I could do anything I felt worth doing was by being a teacher, a scholar, an academic. The thought that all that might come to a sudden end had a dampening effect.”

When Lee J. Cobb—the great Lee J. Cobb, of On the Waterfront and Death of a Salesman fame—explained why he named names, 20 names of former comrades in the Communist Party, he mentioned a great many reasons. But this one always stuck with me: “It’s the only face I have.” This was a man who resisted HUAC for several years. He tried and tried not to capitulate. But when it came down to the blacklist, he couldn’t think of his life apart from his work, and he couldn’t think of his work apart from the luminous—and, God, was it luminous—career he had built for himself as an actor. It was the only face, the only self, he had.

We tend to think that fear works on our basest, most elemental selves, our selves reduced to a purely physical being. It’s often quite the opposite. Fear works most potently and powerfully when it threatens our highest sense of ourselves. We’ll do anything we can to preserve that. Even at the cost of terrible betrayal.


Discover more from Corey Robin

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

5 Comments

  1. William Roark | #

    Hi Corey.

    Wow. Now THAT is something to think about. Prior to your post, I, too, would have thought of hope as the opposition to fear. It had not occurred to me how allied they could be esp. given the differing emotional tonality they seem to instill–or as we stereotype or generalize that

    Explains much: McCarthyism, white supremacy, Trumpism, the defenses and depredations of capitalism, etc.

    Thank you.

  2. Howard | #

    Then there is what Frankl wrote about having a reason to live

  3. Stephen Zielinski | #

    Primo Levi wrote about the prisioner-bricklayers working in Auschwitz. They often were building and repairing the ovens! Why would they do this? To stay alive? They did this work in order to preserve a modicum of dignity they had before the catastrophe that had befallen them. Experience informed them that they too would burn in those ovens. Levi too. He worked as a chemist. Doing so kept him alive and gave him a sense of self apart from the Jude/Untermensch/Häftling identity the Nazis ascribed to him. The cognitive dissonance these individuals likely felt was the cost they paid for remaining alive with a viable sense of self.

  4. Sam Hitt | #

    Those who resisted betraying their comrades during the red scare deserve our admiration not only for their courage but because they lived a truly examined life that overcame fear of the slow demise of their highest hopes and aspirations.

  5. Saaid Saleem | #

    “A man without hope is a man without fear.”

Leave a Reply