Shulamith Firestone and the Private Life of Power
In The Reactionary Mind, I wrote:
One of the reasons the subordinate’s exercise of agency so agitates the conservative imagination is that it takes place in an intimate setting. Every great blast—the storming of the Bastille, the taking of the Winter Palace, the March on Washington—is set off by a private fuse: the contest for rights and standing in the family, the factory, and the field. Politicians and parties talk of constitution and amendment, natural rights and inherited privileges. But the real subject of their deliberations is the private life of power: “Here is the opposition to woman’s equality in the state,” Elizabeth Cady Stanton wrote. “Men are not ready to recognize it in the home.” Behind the riot in the street or debate in Parliament is the maid talking back to her mistress, the worker disobeying her boss. That is why our political arguments—not only about the family but also the welfare state, civil rights, and much else—can be so explosive: they touch upon the most personal relations of power.
Feminism—and the backlash against it—is the paradigm case of the battle over the private life of power. As historians have shown, the attack on Women’s Lib gave the modern conservative movement what it needed to achieve its counterrevolution in 1980. But to understand why that was the case, we have to recall just how radical feminism truly was: it sought to disrupt concrete and tangible relationships in the most private relations of power.
In the current issue of The New Yorker, Susan Faludi has a wonderful profile of Shulamith Firestone, who died last August. Firestone was a pioneering radical feminist whose book The Dialectic of Sex did for feminism what Camus did for existentialism: it gave it a language and a shape, a fixture and a feel. But Firestone was not just the master of suspicion; she was also the master of disruption, organizing actions that confronted male power exactly where it lay: not merely in the far-off halls of Congress or the Supreme Court, but also in the office, the factory floor, the kitchen, the bedroom, the left-wing meeting. Understanding that sexist domination was above all in-your-face, she responded and agitated in kind.
By then, the groups that Firestone had founded, and a host of offshoots, were making headlines with confrontational protests and street theatre. They disrupted state abortion-law hearings in Albany; occupied restaurants that wouldn’t serve “unescorted” women; conducted a “Burial of Traditional Womanhood,” in Arlington National Cemetery (the deceased wore curlers); released dozens of white mice to wreak havoc at a bridal fair at Madison Square Garden; held an “ogle-in” on Wall Street, to dole out some payback to leering men; and, most notorious, hurled brassieres, high heels, pots and pans, copies of Playboy, and other “instruments of female torture” into a Freedom Trash Can at the Miss America pageant, in Atlantic City. When Firestone was fired from a waitressing job and her boss withheld her wages, feminists stormed the restaurant and made him pay her on the spot.
Discover more from Corey Robin
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
-
I dunno. Some of my earliest political memories are the national mockery of the Amherst Sexual Offense Prevention Policy. And I worry that the experience by adults at that time has led to the visceral rejection of feminism I encounter in a lot of my not-explicitly-conservative students, who are their children. And in fact, that reaction is often most potent and most toxic among my female undergrads.
-
Not the experience of just that policy, I mean, but the whole Gingrich-Clinton rejection of “PC” that was so prevalent in the cultural conversation of the early 90s.
-
I think you mean Antioch:
> In 1993 Antioch became the focus of national attention with its “Sexual Offense Prevention Policy.” Under this policy, consent for sexual behavior must be “(a) verbal, (b) mutual, and (c) reiterated for every new level of sexual behavior.”
Surely that *is* worthy of mockery. And more importantly, the thinking that produced it is deeply flawed.
I think the genuine mistakes of feminist thought have something to do with the left-wing rejection of it. As another example, the feminist attitude toward “biotruths” is anti-scientific and, frankly, blatantly contradicts most of our lived experiences. (Like, I can get behind general opposition to “slut-shaming,” but I absolutely cannot get behind a subculture that censors a correct understanding of the *reason* that women lose status for having sex while men gain status for the same thing.)
That feminism has constructed a subculture precluding even discussion of biological sexual differences shows a deep dysfunction (which reaches to areas other than “biotruths”). Feminist subcultures abound with thought-stopping cliches (such as “biotruths” itself) and dangerous conventions of speech-action which shun dissenters. Shut off from outside input by defense-mechanisms, it becomes cult-like, more extreme, incapable of correcting itself.
Anyway, my point here is that rejection of feminism is not necessarily conservative. A lot of people just see it as crazy.
-
-
fantastic read–
but as a 53 yr old feminist, I find the landscape of liberal feminism today utterly devoid of any radicalism at all — only on the severely underreported margins. Whether in pop culture (the truly awful Girls) or ludicrously reductive groups like Femen whose feminism is merely colonialist white supremacy (with pretty young girls showing off their boobs–hardly radical) or fixations on some mildly silly comment from Obama about an attorney general’s looks, I see very little in the current western liberal feminist landscape to be inspired by. I see looks and weight and dress being just as much of an obsession and criteria for judging a woman as existed decades ago.
-
There’s a piece by Chitra Nagarajan in The Guardian on Femen’s alleged “colonial feminism.” I’ve commented on Pussy Riot vs. Femen below. I don’t think Femen are racist or colonialist coming mostly from Ukraine where race and colonialism (other than Russian/Polish imperialism perhaps) are non-issues. Besides, within a narrative of universal progress one has no choice but to accept that Arab societies are indeed backward, whether that sounds racist or not. My issue with Femen is different – I simply don’t see the point of flashing before Putin in Hamburg.
-
-
“the counterrevolution that would soon arise to crush feminism. ??
The women’s movement is alive and well. Social media has allowed contemporary feminism to flourish. Protests against sexual violence are spreading across south Asia. The women of Libya helped overthrow Qaddafi by smuggling arms and spying on the government, and now are fighting for a greater voice in society, a process being repeated in all the Arab Spring countries.
In 1992, Sinéad O’Connor was nearly lynched after she tore up the Pope’s picture on live TV. Now, she is quoted in the Guardian, congratulating Pope Rat Zinger on his ‘greatest act’ – resigning in disgrace. A wave of protests have taken place across Ireland in response to the death of Savita Halappanavar. ‘Slut walks’, Pussy Riot, SWP rape trial…the list is endless.
By the way, at Brooklyn College ‘women’s lib’ and ‘women’s libbers’ are putdowns and are offensive.
-
How is “Women’s Lib” offensive, for it is simply a contraction of Women’s Liberation? It carries no hidden meaning, no deep and dark etymological roots.
-
-
I’m not sure Femen have much to do with white supremacy or colonialism, but I don’t quite see the point of such protest – what exactly was the message, after all? In contrast, Pussy Riot did something quite radical by Russian standards and sent a pretty strong feminist/political/anti-clerical (though not anti-faith) message. One member of the group, though not one of the performers, named Shulamith Firestone as an influence.
Another prominent Russian feminist, Nadya Plungyan, a painter, literary scholar and critic, says she spent years looking for a copy of The Dialectic of Sex and only located one in 2011 or 12 in a Paris bookstore. She opened a random page, it seems, and the first thing that caught her eye was the rights of children and their oppression, a reference mark for power distribution in a society. “I had a feeling of enormous gratitude and sympathy.”
Sinéad found herself a public enemy partly because it was 1992, when John Paul II was idolized for his (probably not insignificant) role in bringing down communism.
-
It seems to me that part of what allowed feminism to succeed was the simultaneous emergence of neoliberalism. Just as women were being told it is good to have a career, the economy was stagnating and the influx of women into the work force helped suppress wages. I am not suggesting that men don’t continue to make more than women – they of course do – but the the large increase of labor helped execute the neoliberal agenda. Now it takes two incomes to sustain a middle class life. And this doesn’t tak into account the consequences of the Great Recession.
-
The form of feminism that we have got today is fundamentally compatible with (or even an extension of) neo-liberalism.
The woman isn’t liberated from dependency, but just given a new option: depend on a boss instead of a man. (I don’t mean to suggest this isn’t an improvement for women; but it’s far from the same thing as designing society to fulfill the needs of women.)
“Wages for housework” or “guaranteed income” or the right to be a single mom *and not work a job* would be anathema to neo-liberalism and of course they aren’t on the feminist agenda anymore (not that they were super prominent in the first place).
-
-
I think he means that people there use the terms pejoratively. Like he’s heard people say things like, “don’t even bother with that one, she’s a women’s libber.”
-
Right right! Sorry.
-
I’m actually a bit young to have much personal experience here but I do find it very difficult to believe that 1993 was the year when the issue of men pressuring women into sex was first raised. The novelty (and ridicule) seems to involve only the special significance attached to (the absence of) verbalization.
As far as your last suggestion, “if it cramps your style, then find a partner who suits your whims or conform. Pretty simple.” —
I really wonder what you mean. Do you mean attend a different college than Antioch? You couldn’t possibly mean that? Yet, at Antioch, no choice of partner could alter the definition of all non-verbal sexual escalation as rape.
I have to wonder if we’re interpreting the rules in the same way here… I just don’t see how what you’re suggesting is possible.
-
Incidentally, Camus was an unpleasant colonial racist who public supported Nazi collaborators such as Maurice Papon who during WWII sent hundreds of French Jews to death camps and in 1961 unleashed a pre-planned massacre of hundreds of demonstrating Algerians in Paris. Camus the Algeria born colonial specialized in serving up half-baked “solutions [that fell] well short of majority rule and self-determination for Algerian Muslims, including bizarre schemes evocative of later Afrikaner designs to retain power in South Africa”. No wonder he’s a hero to Israeli colonists who believe that “there are circumstances in history that justify ethnic cleansing.”.
-
Camus’ half-baked solutions were supposed to prevent a massacre of the pieds-noirs and their Arab/Berber allies (the Hakis). Under majority rule (so he thought) they were all but guaranteed. Indeed, 50 to 150 thousands Hakis were killed in the postwar reprisals.
Whether Camus, and not Sartre, should be counted as the original voice of existentialism, is another question.
-
-
I meant his experience was matched up with what Katha Pollitt had to say. Just to be clear.
-
As the [French] government pressed on with peace negotiations, the OAS carried
out a campaign of slaughter among Algerians and their supporters that
rivaled in little more than a year the number killed in seven years of
FLN terror. It hatched plots against de Gaulle and others in France,
including Sartre. In Algeria this frenzy created the very conditions,
once the FLN took power, that would force the pieds-noirs to abandon
Algeria completely. It was a bloodbath. When Algerian independence was
finally declared in July 1962, one million French Algerians were in the
midst of fleeing to France and Spain, destroying everything they could
not carry with them. Camus was dead, and so was his Algeria.The first OAS bomb aimed at Sartre, in July 1961, had been mistakenly
placed on the floor above the one he lived on; the second in January
1962, damaged his apartment. Sartre and Beauvoir had been holed up at
an acquaintance’s but Sartre’s mother was home. Luckily, she was in
the bathroom when the bomb went off, and was unhurt. Camus had worried
publicly about FLN violence against his mother, but it was Sartre’s mother
who came within a hair’s breadth of being murdered by OAS violence…Certainly Camus’s hatred of Communism was legitimate and was understandably
fueled by his opposition to violence. But like many another anti-Communist,
he wrecked his own moral and political coherence by avoiding talking about
his own society. Casting blame on Soviet ambitions, Camus seemed to analyze
everything but the fundamental changes required to end colonialism. Unable
to speak about what his people would have to give up to become merely equal
citizens, indeed a minority in postcolonial Algeria, Camus fell silent.http://books.google.com/books?isbn=0226000249
de Gaulle was almost murdered by the quasi-Fascist OAS the same year they blew up Sartre’s apartment:
-
“released dozens of white mice to wreak havoc at a bridal fair at Madison Square Garden; held an “ogle-in” on Wall Street, to dole out some payback to leering men; and, most notorious, hurled brassieres, high heels, pots and pans, copies of Playboy, and other “instruments of female torture” into a Freedom Trash Can at the Miss America pageant, in Atlantic City.”
You have to admit, those were pretty stupid, pointless things to do. Really, they demonstrate the political immaturity of sections of the feminist movement. Can you honestly say that someone who calls Playboy an “instrument of female torture” is not a idiot?
Feminists need to stop glorifying inchoate rage and accepting every damn thing other feminists do and start coming up with serious, coherent theory based on fact, not the lit-critty interpretations of life that constitute what passes for feminist theory at the moment.
-
“By the way, at Brooklyn College ‘women’s lib’ and ‘women’s libbers’ are putdowns and are offensive.”
So what? If feminists don’t have the strength to brush off insults they won’t get very far.
-
Corey, I love this. Celebrating both Faludi and Firestone in the wake of all the “Lean In” silliness is fantabulous. On the Antioch hulabalooh, which I remember well, I have suggested to the young men in my sexual ethics classes at Duke that living by such rules could be really great for them, in that they will enjoy knowing that the woman with them truly, really, wants them. And, if a man doesn’t find it really sexy for a woman to be very, very clear that she totally wants him, he probably has no business being with a woman . . . Regarding mice, bras-on-fire, and the like, such dramatic play is one way to deal with Godzilla and not be totally squished. (Now sort of wondering if the mice all escaped . . .) Mary Daly coined the term “gynergy” in part to name the kind of power that women expend when trying to engage with, live within, alter a patriarchal system. (If a reader balks at the term “patriarchal system,” not sure how to fix that in one “comment.”) Street theater is a way to reclaim spaces of intimidation as places for re-creative speech. The “winnable” in such organizing is less obvious than in most IAF efforts, but it can be a lively part of a movement to thwart artistically the usual rules by which we march dutifully around a campus, neighborhood, workplace, etc.